Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

'Give patients data choice'

Informed consent is vital when collecting medical records, says expert

ON SEPTEMBER 1, 2021, NHS Digital will collect General Practice data for Planning and Research (GPDPR) in England.


According to the NHS Digital website, the data will be used to “support a wide variety of research and analysis to help run and improve health and care services”. The data will also be used “to understand whether the health and care system as a whole is working for patients”.

In line with information governance policies, the data collected will both be pseudonymised and then encrypted before it leaves an individual’s GP practice. Data will only be shared with organisations who have a legal basis and meet strict criteria to use the information for local, regional and national planning, policy development, commissioning, public health and research purposes.

The data collection was delayed following public backlash and concerns1 raised by the British Medical Association (BMA) and the Royal College of GPs (RCGP). Even though the BMA and RCGP were “supportive of the principles of the new collection in promoting data sharing for appropriate purposes and centralising oversight and safeguarding”, they have formally expressed “concerns about the lack of communication with the public regarding the GPDPR programme”.

Originally, patients had until Wednesday (23) to opt out of sharing their private GP medical records, but given the backlash, it would seem that most were not even remotely aware of the plans. It is important to note that patients can still opt out of having their data share by registering via the Type 1 Opt-out2 or a National Data Opt-out3, or both.

The NHS Digital leadership rightfully highlighted the benefits that collecting this data can have on patient care4.

As health care is becoming more digitalised, the sharing of data is more important than ever before. Video calling clinicians and health care apps are no longer the future, but our present. Covid-19 has also accelerated the adoption of some of these new technologies and new ways of working.

There are many health conditions which disproportionately affect ethnic minorities, including coronary heart disease, diabetes, prostate cancer and Covid-19. Data collection for research and new technologies can help to reduce the inequalities seen in these and other conditions.

During a visit to an optician recently I also discovered that one of the eye scans took my age and ethnicity into consideration to make sure nothing relevant to me as a middle-aged black African man was missed. This was a reminder and example of how data can be used to provide better care for all.

While the NHS Race and Health Observatory (RHO) supports the principles and rationale behind the data collection, we initially had concerns around the proposals not being widely known or shared across inclusive platforms for diverse communities, including those who may need translations. In the run-up to the original proposed opt-out date, we became aware of details on the programme being shared via social media platforms.

Where there is a lack of awareness and information over public health messaging, this can lead to additional confusion if individuals are not aware or do not receive timely communications. The case of the failed Care.data plan eight years ago is a case in point. The public in general, and ethnic minorities in particular, need to be fully aware of the benefits of data collection; be informed of what options are available to opt out and given sufficient time to do further research and decide on their preference.

Even though the Covid-19 pandemic has disproportionately affected people from an ethnic minority background, the vaccine uptake among ethnic minorities remains significantly lower than that of people from a white background.

Research by Healthwatch exploring vaccination confidence among people from African, Bangladeshi, Caribbean and Pakistani backgrounds living in the UK found that “at the root of the problem are institutional mistrust and misinformation – and that is what the healthcare sector and policymakers need to address. Addressing mistrust and misinformation about NHS programmes could also help reduce health inequalities at a local level.”

Research by the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine looking at factors influencing uptake of Covid vaccines found that “refusal is higher among health and social care workers who feel pressured by their employers”.

The NHS must show it has learned lessons from the vaccination programme and give people from ethnic minority backgrounds time to make informed decisions, instead of pressuring them. It will help to rebuild the trust that has been eroded by decades of unequal experiences and outcomes for people from an ethnic minority background. It is critical that people are not only informed through trusted channels, but also be given time to consent or decline to their medical information being shared. It is important that such a wide-ranging programme is accompanied by the right public-facing messages that are culturally sensitive and inclusive.

This is also an opportunity for the NHS as a whole to start addressing the issue of ethnicity coding in these data sets. The recently published research by the Nuffield Trust, in collaboration with the RHO, looked at ethnicity coding in English health service datasets. It found that there is still much more work to do to improve the quality of ethnicity coding in health care records5. Using incomplete or inaccurate data might have an adverse impact when trying to understand and reduce health inequalities.

The RHO is willing to work with all those involved in the patient data opt-out programme to develop appropriate information and to share it.

  • Owen Chinembir is senior implementation lead for the NHS RHO.

    References:

    1. www.rcgp.org.uk/-/media/Files/News/rcgp-bma-letter-gpdpr.ashx?la=en

    2. digital.nhs.uk/your-data/opting-out-of-data-sharing

    3. www.nhs.uk/your-nhs-data-matters/manage-your-choice/

    4. www.digitalhealth.net/2021/05/nhs-digital-announces-new-primary-care-data-collection-service/

    5. www.nhsrho.org/wp-content/ uploads/ 2021/06/Nuffield-Trust-Ethnicity-coding_WEB.pdf

  • More For You

    Does likeability count more than brilliance?

    Higher education participation is 50 per cent for British south Asian students

    Does likeability count more than brilliance?

    THE headline in the Daily Telegraph read: An 18-year-old with a higher IQ than Stephen Hawking has passed 23 A-levels.

    The gushing piece went on to report that Mahnoor Cheema, whose family originate from Pakistan, had also received an unconditional offer from Oxford University to read medicine.

    Keep ReadingShow less
    Comment: Why it’s vital to tell stories
of Asian troops’ war effort

    Jay Singh Sohal on Mandalay Hill in Burma at the position once held by Sikh machine gunners who fought to liberate the area

    Comment: Why it’s vital to tell stories of Asian troops’ war effort

    Jay Singh Sohal OBE VR

    ACROSS the Asian subcontinent 80 years ago, the guns finally fell silent on August 15, the Second World War had truly ended.

    Yet, in Britain, what became known as VJ Day often remains a distant afterthought, overshadowed by Victory in Europe against the Nazis, which is marked three months earlier.

    Keep ReadingShow less
    Judicial well-being: From taboo to recognition by the UN

    The causes of judicial stress are multifaceted, and their effects go far beyond individual well-being

    iStock

    Judicial well-being: From taboo to recognition by the UN

    Justice Rangajeeva Wimalasena

    Judicial well-being has long been a taboo subject, despite the untold toll it has taken on judges who must grapple daily with the problems and traumas of others. Research shows that judicial stress is more pronounced among magistrates and trial judges, who routinely face intense caseloads and are exposed to distressing material. The causes of judicial stress are multifaceted, and their effects go far beyond individual well-being. They ultimately affect the integrity of the institution and the quality of justice delivered. This is why judicial well-being requires serious recognition and priority.

    As early as 1981, American clinical psychologist Isaiah M. Zimmerman presented one of the first and most comprehensive analyses of the impact of stress on judges. He identified a collection of stressors, including overwhelming caseloads, isolation, the pressure to maintain a strong public image, and the loneliness of the judicial role. He also highlighted deeply personal challenges such as midlife transitions, marital strain, and diminishing career satisfaction, all of which quietly but persistently erode judicial well-being.

    Keep ReadingShow less
    Fauja Singh

    Fauja Singh

    Getty Images

    What Fauja Singh taught me

    I met Fauja Singh twice, once when we hiked Snowdon and I was in awe he was wearing shoes, not trainers and walking like a pro, no fear, just smiling away. I was struggling to do the hike with trainers. I remember my mum saying “what an inspiration”. He was a very humble and kind human being. The second time I met him was when I was at an event, and again, he just had such a radiant energy about him. He’s one of a kind and I’m blessed to have met him.

    He wasn’t just a runner. He was a symbol. A living contradiction to everything we’re taught about age, limits, and when to stop dreaming. And now that he’s gone, it feels like a light has gone out—not just in Punjab or east London, but in the hearts of everyone who saw a bit of themselves in his journey.

    Keep ReadingShow less
    “Why can’t I just run?”: A south Asian woman’s harrowing harassment story

    Minreet with her mother

    “Why can’t I just run?”: A south Asian woman’s harrowing harassment story

    I was five years old when my parents first signed me up for a mini marathon. They were both keen runners and wanted me to follow in their footsteps. At the time, I hated it. Running felt like punishment — exhausting, uncomfortable, and something I never imagined I’d do by choice.

    But one moment changed everything. I was 12, attending a gymnastics competition, and had gone to the car alone to grab my hula hoop. As I walked back, a group of men started shouting at me. They moved closer. I didn’t wait to hear what they had to say — I ran. Fast. My heart was pounding. It was the first time I felt afraid simply for existing in public as a young girl. I never told anyone. But I remember feeling thankful, strangely, that my parents had taught me how to run.

    Keep ReadingShow less