Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Supreme Court rules against separate business rates assessment of ATMs

The Supreme Court  has held that ATMs in stores should not be assessed separately for business rates.

On May 20, the court unanimously dismissed an appeal filed by Valuation Office Agency (VOA) challenging a Court of Appeal ruling that ATMs located both inside and outside of stores should not be assessed for additional business rates.


“External ATMs are to be treated the same as internal ones. That an external ATMs is available to a wider marker at all times, and is physically separated from the other facilities in the stores, does not detract from the Upper Tribunal’s finding that the retailers remained in occupation of the ATMs, nor that they were any less a part of the retailers’ businesses,” the court said in its judgement.

“The difference is no greater than the difference between an internal or external ATM in a bank building. Thus, the external ATMs remained in the rateable occupation of the retailers.”

The judgment came in a lengthy legal battle led by ATM operator Cardtronics and supermarket chains Tesco, Sainsbury’s and the Co-op.

The Valuation Tribunal for England initially decided that the ATM sites were in separate rateable occupation, but the Upper Tribunal in January 2017 made a distinction between ATMs inside a building and outside.

The Upper Tribunal had said that the sites of ATMs located within premises should not be assessed for business rates, but ‘through the wall’ external-facing ATMs should, which was later overturned by the Court of Appeal in November 2018.

“Retaining the imposition of rates on ATMs would have had huge ramifications not only for the industry, but the provision of available cash to spend locally and where needed. More so than ever, in the current climate, the right decision has been upheld by the court,” commented Emily Wood, partner at law firm DMH Stallard, who represented Cardtronics in the litigation.

Cardtronics said the ruling will help retailers to recover the estimated £300 million in business rates paid on ATM sites since 2010.

“This decision will benefit small businesses and local high streets, and the vital role they will play in the UK economy once the current lockdown has been lifted,” commented Marc Terry, international managing director of Cardtronics.

“Cardtronics’ data shows that the vast majority of ATM users spend the money they withdraw in the store which hosts the machine. In today’s challenging business environment, this additional footfall will be a vital contributor to the survival of many of our local high street businesses.”

The Association of Convenience Stores (ACS) chief executive James Lowman said the judgment will have a huge impact on the sector and urged the government to set up a simple refund process.

“This is a landmark ruling from the Supreme Court which will have huge impact on our sector and will help maintain widespread access to cash,” he said.

“It had become increasingly difficult for retailers to host ATMs with the high cost of business rates and cuts to interchange fees. The government now needs to implement the Supreme Court ruling by setting up a simple refund process which ensures full compensation is paid to all retailers who have been subject to wrongful business rates bills for ATMs”.

Figures from the 2019 Local Shop Report by the ACS show that 46 percent of convenience stores have a free to use cash machine, with 18 percent having a pay to use machine.

More For You

Government steps in as JLR cyber attack stalls output

FILE PHOTO: A member of staff works on the production line at Jaguar Land Rover’s factory in Solihull, Britain. REUTERS/Phil Noble

Government steps in as JLR cyber attack stalls output

BRITAIN's largest carmaker, Jaguar Land Rover, said a pause in production due to a cyber attack would now stretch to September 24, extending the stoppage at its plants to more than three weeks.

The luxury carmaker, owned by India's Tata Motors, said it shut down its systems in early September to contain the hack that has severely disrupted its retail and manufacturing operations.

Keep ReadingShow less
UK–Africa business summit 2025

UK–Africa business summit 2025

UK–Africa business summit 2025 highlights trade, technology and resilient partnerships

Highlights:

  • Dr Sudhir Ruparelia emphasised Uganda’s growing real estate, agriculture and tourism sectors.
  • Lord Dolar Popat called for closer Commonwealth ties between Africa, the UK and India.
  • Uganda’s ministers outlined regional integration, investment climate and agricultural transformation.
  • Spiritual leader Sant Trilochan Darshan Das Ji urged ethical entrepreneurship rooted in integrity.

The 15th edition of the UK–Africa Business Summit took place on Friday, 12 September at The Royal Horseguards Hotel & One Whitehall Place, bringing together senior government leaders, entrepreneurs, investors and diaspora stakeholders to strengthen trade and investment ties between the UK and African nations.

Keep ReadingShow less
Modi & Trump

Donald Trump and Narendra Modi shake hands as they attend a joint press conference at the White House on February 13, 2025.

Reuters

India, US to discuss trade issues after tariff hike

INDIA and the United States will hold trade discussions in New Delhi on Tuesday, officials and Indian media reports said, as the two countries look to resolve a tariff dispute.

India currently faces high US tariffs on most of its exports and has not yet been able to reach a trade deal that would ease the pressure.

Keep ReadingShow less
Piyush Goyal

Piyush Goyal recalled that in February, Narendra Modi and Donald Trump had instructed their trade ministers to conclude the first phase of the bilateral trade agreement (BTA) by November 2025. (Photo: Getty Images)

Getty Images

Trade talks with US moving forward positively, says Indian minister Goyal

INDIA’s commerce and industry minister Piyush Goyal on Thursday said that negotiations on the proposed trade agreement between India and the United States, which began in March, are progressing in a positive atmosphere and both sides are satisfied with the discussions.

He recalled that in February, Indian prime minister Narendra Modi and US president Donald Trump had instructed their trade ministers to conclude the first phase of the bilateral trade agreement (BTA) by November 2025.

Keep ReadingShow less
Baiju Bhatt

At 40, Bhatt is the only person of Indian origin in this group, which includes figures such as Meta’s Mark Zuckerberg. (Photo: Getty Images)

Baiju Bhatt named among youngest billionaires in US by Forbes

INDIAN-AMERICAN entrepreneur Baiju Bhatt, co-founder of the commission-free trading platform Robinhood, has been named among the 10 youngest billionaires in the United States in the 2025 Forbes 400 list.

At 40, Bhatt is the only person of Indian origin in this group, which includes figures such as Meta’s Mark Zuckerberg. Forbes estimates his net worth at around USD 6–7 billion (£4.4–5.1 billion), primarily from his roughly 6 per cent ownership in Robinhood.

Keep ReadingShow less